The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Extra Virgin Olive Oil
A good extra virgin olive oil can transform even the simplest dish into a magical fusion of flavors. Not only does it offer immeasurable health benefits, but it also elevates your culinary creations. Discover the secrets to selecting top-quality extra virgin olive oil and learn how it can enhance your cooking.
What is Extra Virgin Olive Oil?
Extra virgin olive oil is the pure, pressed juice of crushed olives. Much like wine, the variety of olive used brings unique characteristics to the oil. With over 1,000 olive varietals globally, the flavor variations are endless. Italy, home to more than 500 olive varieties, is renowned for its diverse and high-quality oils, many of which are difficult to find abroad.
How to Choose a Good Extra Virgin Olive Oil
When selecting and purchasing a good extra virgin olive oil, consider these factors:
Color
While the color of olive oil can range from deep grassy green to lighter golden hues, the key is its intensity. Fresh, new oils may appear opaque or cloudy. Remember, color is never an indicator of quality; often, oil tastings are conducted blind to avoid judging a “book by the cover”.
Smell
Good olive oil should smell pungent and fruity. If the oil smells rancid or stale—like motor oil, crayons, or rotting fruit—it’s a sign of poor quality.
Taste
To taste olive oil, sip a little and suck it through your teeth. A good oil should have a slight spiciness, fresh herby fruitiness, and a touch of bitterness. It shouldn’t leave a greasy residue but should instead leave your mouth feeling clean.
Cold Press
Cold-pressed oils are treated without heat, preserving the fresh elements of the olives. Look for “cold-pressed” or “cold-extracted” on the label to ensure better quality.
Cost
With olive oil, you get what you pay for. Investing in high-quality extra virgin olive oil from a good producer will enhance the flavor of your dishes and prove to be more cost-effective in the long run.
Storage
Olive oil should be stored in dark glass or metal containers to prevent light exposure, which can cause rancidity. Keep your oil away from sunlight and use it within two years. Wrapping bottles in aluminum foil can also help protect the oil.
Benefits of Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Extra virgin olive oil is a superfood packed with antioxidants and vitamins. It is an essential component of a healthy Mediterranean diet. Avoid anything labeled as ‘light’ or ‘diet’ olive oil, as these are unnecessary and inferior to genuine extra virgin olive oil.
Food Pairings
Experimenting with different extra virgin olive oils is as exciting as pairing wines. Each oil’s unique attributes can enhance various foods. A well-stocked Italian kitchen will have multiple olive oils for different purposes. Invest in a few high-quality bottles and explore the delightful possibilities.
Dive deeper into the world of Italian extra virgin olive oil with our olive oil sommelier on our Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Tasting in Rome or our Olive Oil Tasting and Full Homemade Family Meal in Rome
Join Our Community
For more authentic and traditional Italian experiences, join our Community Casa Local Aromas and immerse yourself in the true essence of Italy.
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel and check out our food and wine tours and cooking classes in Rome, Florence, and Venice!